The recent Elden Ring DLC has sparked debate among fans regarding its lore’s connection to the base game. Did FromSoftware meticulously weave foreshadowing throughout the Lands Between, or did the DLC introduce entirely new characters and storylines out of the blue?
Elden Ring: Did the DLC Foreshadow Enough?
A Shadow of Doubt: Missing Pieces in the Base Game
Players point to a glaring absence of references to crucial DLC figures. Messmer, Miquella’s betrothed Radahn, and Rennala’s sister Rellana are entirely unknown quantities in the base game. This lack of familiarity can be jarring, particularly for lore enthusiasts who meticulously piece together the game’s narrative tapestry.
Furthermore, the DLC’s location, the Shadowlands, feels like a separate entity. Its unique architecture and resources stand in stark contrast to the established environments of the Lands Between. This disconnect can leave players wondering if they’ve stumbled into an entirely different game.
Flickering Embers: Potential Hints of What Lies Beneath
Those defending the lore’s cohesion argue that the vastness of Elden Ring’s narrative allows for hidden depths. The DLC, they posit, unveils details previously shrouded in mystery. The very nature of the “shadow” theme could represent hidden lore, with Marika actively suppressing knowledge of Messmer and the Shadowlands.
Supporters also point to subtle hints scattered throughout the base game. The positioning and shadows of the Divine Towers could be interpreted as cryptic clues towards a hidden area beneath the map (where the DLC takes place). Additionally, the fire butterflies initially associated with Melina might be seen as foreshadowing for Messmer’s fire-based powers, although some argue the DLC retcons these butterflies to belong to Melina.
Unraveling the Truth: Intentional Mystery or Development Decisions?
Two possible explanations emerge from this debate. Perhaps the lack of overt foreshadowing is intentional. The “shadow” theme translates into hidden lore, rewarding players who delve deeper. This approach aligns with FromSoftware’s signature cryptic storytelling.
Alternatively, the developers might not have fully fleshed out the DLC concept during base game development. This could explain the seemingly abrupt introduction of new characters and locations in the DLC.
Conclusion: A Matter of Perspective
The debate surrounding the Elden Ring DLC lore boils down to how players interpret foreshadowing and narrative cohesion in open-world games. Some crave explicit hints that guide them towards future lore reveals. Others relish the thrill of uncovering hidden depths within a seemingly complete world. Ultimately, how you perceive the DLC’s connection to the base game hinges on your individual preferences.
!! NEW: Free Games & Discounts: Epic Games & Steam Tracker →
